PMA Karachi and Larkano unite against “Illegal” SHCC appointments
Doctors warn any nomination made without Selection Committee will be challenged in Sindh High Court; Health Department remains silent despite repeated efforts
KARACHI / LARKANA: Two
chapters of the Pakistan Medical Association (PMA) in Sindh — Karachi and
Larkano — have reacted in the same pattern against the proposed reconstitution
of the Board of Commissioners of the Sindh Healthcare Commission (SHCC),
warning that any appointment made without following the law will be challenged
in the Sindh High Court.
The joint protest
came after the Health Minister disclosed in the Sindh Assembly on November 18,
2026, that the SHCC has been functioning without a Chairperson for the past 18
months, following the expiry of the previous Board’s tenure.
While both chapters
support the immediate restoration of the Commission, they allege that the
Health Department has forwarded names of proposed Commissioners directly to the
Provincial Cabinet, bypassing the mandatory Selection Committee required under
the law.
Despite repeated
efforts by this blog to get the official version, the Sindh Health Department
has not responded to PMA’s objections so far.
PMA Karachi: “Process is challengeable”
PMA Karachi, in a
press release issued by General Secretary Dr Shahid Mamsa, expressed serious
concern over the reported move.
PMA Karachi
emphasised that Section 5 of the Sindh Healthcare Commission Act, 2013,
provides a specific procedure for recommending Commissioners through a
statutory Selection Committee, which includes representation from the Pakistan
Medical Association.
Bypassing this process, PMA Karachi warned, may constitute a violation of the prescribed legal framework and render the nominations legally challengeable.
PMA Karachi
demanded that the Government of Sindh defer the proposed appointments until the
mandatory statutory procedure has been followed, direct the Health Department
to immediately convene the Selection Committee with participation of all
statutory members including the PMA representative, and ensure transparent,
merit-based and legally compliant nominations.
PMA Karachi warned
that proceeding without fulfilling statutory requirements may compel the
Association to seek appropriate legal remedy before the Honourable High Court
of Sindh.
PMA Larkano:
“Reject the summary”
PMA Larkano adopted
a stronger tone in its press release of November 19, 2026, strongly condemning
what it called the Sindh Health Department’s unlawful attempt to bypass
statutory procedures.
PMA Larkano said it
had learned with grave concern that proposed names have been forwarded directly
to the Provincial Cabinet without convening the mandatory Selection Committee.
Under Section 5 of
the SHCC Act, 2013, PMA Larkano said, all nominations must be scrutinised and
recommended by a statutory Selection Committee that includes PMA
representation.
Bypassing this
body, PMA Larkano alleged, renders the process illegal and undermines the
Commission’s independence to regulate healthcare standards and combat quackery
across Sindh.
PMA Larkano
demanded that the Provincial Cabinet immediately reject any summary of proposed
SHCC Commissioners not vetted through the statutory Selection Committee, and
that the Health Department immediately convene the Selection Committee with
full participation of all statutory stakeholders, including the PMA, to ensure
merit-based appointments.
PMA Larkano warned
that if any unlawful appointments are notified in violation of Section 5, the
Association will be compelled to challenge the notifications before the
Honourable High Court of Sindh.
A common pattern, growing pressure
Although issued
separately, the two statements follow an identical legal pattern — same Act,
same Section 5, same demand for a Selection Committee, and same warning of court
action.
Medical circles in
Sindh say more PMA chapters may follow the same pattern in the coming days if
the government does not clarify its position. PMA leaders argue that a
Commission formed in violation of its own Act cannot credibly regulate hospitals,
clinics and quackery in the province.
PMA has urged the
Government of Sindh to ensure transparency, merit and strict adherence to law
in the constitution of this important healthcare regulatory body.
In the meantime, a Sindh CM House communication on the
decisions of the Sindh Cabinet meeting chaired by Chief Minister Syed Murad Ali
Shah on Thursday said the cabinet also approved
Dr Amjad Siraj from the public-sector panel and Dr Saeed Qureshi from the
private-sector panel for the selection committee relating to the Sindh
Healthcare Commission.
--IV Desk
Illustrations: AI-generated editorial
illustrations for Indus Vitals.
Images: ST



Comments
Post a Comment